The accumulation and aggregation of alpha-synuclein (α-Syn) are pathological processes associated with Parkinson’s disease, indicating that the regulation of protein is a crucial etiopathological mechanism. Interestingly, human serum and cerebrospinal fluid contain autoantibodies that recognize α-Syn. This potentially demonstrates an already existing, naturally decomposing, and protective system. Thus, quantitative or qualitative alterations, such as the modified antigen binding of so-called naturally occurring autoantibodies against α-Syn (nAbs-α-Syn), may induce disease onset and/or progression. We investigated the serum titers and binding characteristics of nAbs-α-Syn in patients suffering from sporadic Parkinson’s disease (n = 38), LRRK2 mutation carriers (n = 25), and healthy controls (n = 22). Methods: Titers of nAbs-α-Syn were assessed with ELISA and binding affinities and kinetics with SPR. Within the patient cohort, we discriminated between idiopathic and genetic (LRRK2-mutated) variants. Results: ELISA experiments revealed no significant differences in nAbs-α-Syn serum titers among the three cohorts. Moreover, the α-Syn avidity of nAbs-α-Syn was also unchanged. Conclusions: Our findings indicate that nAbs-α-Syn concentrations or affinities in healthy and diseased persons do not differ, independent of mutations in LRRK2.